Urban Ore), I would have been thrilled with even a functional shelving unit. But then this - with coordinating doors, drawers, and the desk - w00t!
If someone would have told me last year that I could fit this large additional piece of furniture in my classroom, I would have laughed. To give you an idea, here is a picture (below) of my science classroom from the far back corner of the room. It is not large by any means, and space is at a premium. With 24 eighth graders in there, things get pretty tight. But, we figured out a way to make it work.
If you look to the far right of the picture, you might also see three 4-foot tables that I rescued from various spots from around the school. After tightening some screws and lining them up, they represent our "design studio" with a couple of old laptops, our Makerbot* and our newest Printrbot*. These tables, in addition to the shelving unit required us to push the lab tables even closer together.
But the loss of space due to the additional furniture was worth it, for it made a dedicated space for all of our tools. We have a bin for MaKey MaKey*, Arduino*, Raspberry Pi* and a LilyPad*. We also have drawers designated for batteries, safety glasses, duct tape, measuring tapes, sewing supplies*, felt* and timers. We have shelves for our one set of Makedo*, books* (including my favorites!), Make Magazines*, a used Kinect scanner*, clipboards & small dry erase boards for planning, and a bunch of items from a resale shop that we hope to eventually 3D scan. We have a bin clearly marked "tools" and a designated space for the soldering iron* and glue guns. There's even a bin labeled "raw materials" which hold cardboard and other assorted scraps for spontaneous making.
What is most interesting to me is that, besides the electronics equipment, most of these materials are new in my classroom. What is new is their visibility and accessibility. Before, these supplies lived in a bin or in some cabinet, only to be taken out when part of an activity in the curriculum. But now, students have been coming in on their free time and lunch periods to calibrate the Printrbot or expand on some idea they are working on with MaKey MaKey. When some kid comments, "I think the gear is stuck," another student will respond by grabbing the pliers out of the tool bin, or when some kid lost the plastic scraper for our 3D printer, another kid jumped on Thingiverse, downloaded an stl file, and printed a replacement. For the first time, students do not have to go through me to access the materials - they figure out what they need and know where to find it. And they are starting to train each other how to use the various equipment, increasing their own buy-in, and decreasing my workload! It feels like a working space, and the kids are taking advantage of it. We even have a Google Doc linked off our class wiki where kids post things "we" need (currently: conductive thread/paint, an HDMI to VGA converter, etc).
If someone would have told me last year that I could make a makerspace in my room, I would have been quick to list all of the limitations of my teaching situation: I don't have enough time, materials, budget or training. I don't have the support of a university, a grant, or other donations. But, we started small and took it one step at a time. For my budget, I started (well before the shelving unit arrived) with an after school 3D Printing (eventually renamed "Maker") club. To my advantage, students do pay for extracurricular activities at my school and, like many start-ups, I chose not to give myself a 'salary' the first few trimesters, instead using that extra money to buy materials. (All of the starred materials above (*) were paid for out of my pocket.) To fill the role of "lab coordinator," I used these self-selected, motivated, after-school kids to experiment with the tools and become the experts I could later use in my science class. And time... well, yeah... I spent a LOT of time playing, learning, and developing a network of resources. But when you love what you do, the line between work and fun is often blurred.
So, do I wish I had more space for student to tinker and make things? Absolutely. But I knew I couldn't wait until I had the perfect space (and materials) to make that happen. Instead I had to make the space - both physical and (more importantly) perceived. I used to give all the credit to that shelving unit, but we're starting to realize that the shelf does far more than just hold the supplies, it helped shift the attitude from classroom to makerspace by keeping already existing tools visible and accessible, and empowering the kids to use them.
If you want to read more about the specifically 3D printing things we are up to, you can visit the blog I created with the kids: Tales of a 3D Printer.
Added 11.2.13: Here are some resources I find myself referring back to: an Edutopia article on Designing a School Makerspace, the MAKE article Is it a Hackerspace, Makerspace, TechShop, or FabLab? and an instagram photo of a makerspace I aspire towards!
Here are some other local under-construction makerspaces (updated)
- Belle Haven Elementary, Menlo Park, CA